Review Criteria

The evaluation criteria that will be followed to analyze the relevance of a document sent for possible publication are:

  1. Contribution to knowledge:
    • Originality 
    • Contribution of new methodologies
    • Development of new theories
    • Topicality of the topic
  2. Theoretical framework
    • Critical review of the state of the art
    • Critical analysis of case studies
    • Theory
  3. Methodological framework
    • Rigor in the selection of specialized and recognized documentary sources 
    • Management evaluation and updating of information sources
    • Correspondence of the methodology with the objectives of the research and / or theoretical reflection
    • Obtaining results
    • Representativeness, validity and reliability of statistical data
  4. Analytical level
    • Depth in reflection
    • Argumentation of the statements made in the reflection on the results that dialogues with the theory, the analytical framework and the objectives
  5. Style
    • Structure
    • Exposition
    • Language
  6. Bibliographic references
    • Quotes
    • Correspondence and articulation between the title, problem, objective, theoretical and methodological framework and conclusions.